Skip to content

Contingent Cargo Insurance for Freight Brokers: What It Covers

Contingent cargo insurance protects a broker when the carrier's cargo policy does not pay. What it covers, how it differs, and where coverage can fail.

Sealed trailer doors beside a policy document and a brass padlock

Contingent cargo insurance protects a freight broker when the motor carrier's cargo insurance is inadequate or does not respond to a loss. It backs up the carrier's own cargo policy and does not replace it.

Brokers buy it because the shipper's agreement is with the broker, and the carrier's policy does not always pay.

Why brokers carry contingent cargo insurance

Federal law sets no cargo insurance requirement for most motor carriers of property. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) lists a cargo insurance requirement of $0 for for-hire property carriers. Only household goods carriers have a federal cargo requirement, of $5,000 [1][2].

Brokers have no federal cargo insurance requirement either. A broker must keep $75,000 in financial security on file with FMCSA, through a BMC-84 surety bond or a BMC-85 trust [1]. That security pays shippers or carriers "if the broker fails to carry out its contracts, agreements, or arrangements" [3]. It is not cargo insurance. Our freight broker insurance guide, linked at the end of this article, covers the bond and the other policies a brokerage carries.

So the carrier's cargo limit is whatever the carrier chose to buy, and whatever its policy agrees to pay on that loss.

Who is liable for lost freight

Under the Carmack Amendment, the carrier is liable for "the actual loss or injury to the property" it transports [4]. The carrier can limit that liability by written agreement, and a shipper has at least 9 months to file a claim and 2 years to sue [4].

Carmack generally does not apply to brokers. The Eleventh Circuit said so in 2018, and added that a party is not a broker under Carmack "if it has agreed with the shipper to accept legal responsibility for that shipment" [5]. A broker that acts like a carrier with a shipper can be treated as one.

A broker can still owe the shipper under its own contract. In a 2022 Pennsylvania case, a broker's agreement required its carriers to carry a set amount of cargo insurance. An impostor used a legitimate carrier's stolen identity and a fake insurance certificate to take two loads of beef. The court held that the broker breached the contract by accepting the certificate "at face value," and that federal law did not preempt the shipper's breach-of-contract claim [6].

How contingent cargo differs from the carrier's cargo policy

QuestionCarrier's policyContingent policy
Who buys itThe motor carrierThe freight broker
Whose liability it coversThe carrier's, for freight it haulsThe broker's, when the carrier's cover fails
When it should payFirst, when the carrier is liableWhen the carrier's insurance is inadequate or does not respond
A condition to checkThe truck is on the policy, and the loss is a covered causeProof of the carrier's insurance before you tender the load

A carrier's policy can fail on the facts of the load. In a 2024 federal case in Utah, an owner-operator hauling for a company was robbed at gunpoint. The company's motor truck cargo insurer first denied the claim because the truck was not on the policy's vehicle schedule. In court, the insurer also argued that the cargo was not in the company's "care, custody, and control," because an independent contractor owned and drove the van. The court agreed on that ground and granted summary judgment to the insurer [7].

Where contingent cargo coverage can fail

Each contingent cargo policy has its own conditions and exclusions. Three gaps matter most for brokers.

The carrier's insurance was never real

In the 2022 Pennsylvania case, the broker held contingent cargo liability coverage of $250,000 per occurrence. The court noted evidence that the broker itself "determined that such a claim would not be covered due to the Carrier's fraudulent insurance certificate" [6]. FMCSA also warns that "even insurance certificates can be fraudulent" [8].

The theft was a deceptive pickup

In an April 2026 public service announcement, the FBI described thieves who pose as a compromised carrier, "double-broker the load to partially unwitting drivers," and change the legitimate carrier's contact information with FMCSA [9]. A loss like this is a strategic theft. A cargo policy may exclude it or cover it only by endorsement, so ask your agent which applies to yours.

The loss is not cargo

Cargo insurance pays for the freight. It does not pay for the truck or trailer, for stock sitting in a fixed warehouse, or for injury and property damage claims after a crash [10]. A reefer unit failure that spoils a load is excluded on most base forms and needs a refrigeration breakdown endorsement [10].

Questions to ask about your contingent cargo policy

  1. What must I do before I tender a load to keep coverage, and how must I prove it?
  2. Does the carrier's insurer have to deny the claim first?
  3. Does the policy cover a fictitious pickup or other strategic theft?
  4. Does it cover a load the carrier passed to another carrier without my consent?
  5. Are any commodities excluded or limited?
  6. What is the limit per occurrence, and can I raise it for one high-value load?
  7. Is the insurer admitted in my state, or is the coverage written on a surplus lines basis?

On the last question: surplus lines insurers do not generally participate in state guaranty funds, so their policyholders are not protected by those funds [10][11].

How to keep contingent cargo coverage valid

  1. Get the carrier's certificate of insurance before you tender, and confirm it with the insurer or agent named on it, not only by email.
  2. Check that the carrier's cargo limit is equal to or more than the value of the load.
  3. Confirm that the truck that arrives belongs to the carrier you booked.
  4. Keep the certificate, the confirmation, and the pickup checks with the load.
  5. When a load is worth more than your policy limit, arrange more coverage for that shipment before it moves.

If a load is lost, the shipper will ask which carrier had it and what you checked. These records answer both questions.

Contingent cargo coverage from Indemni

Indemni Insurance Agency offers contingent cargo liability for brokers and 3PLs on an annual policy with limits up to $1M. When one shipment's value exceeds the annual limit, you can ask to raise the limit for that shipment only [10]. Coverage options include All-Risk with Strategic Theft, which covers deceptive pickups, or Strategic Theft alone [10].

Indemni's program requires the broker to obtain proof of the carrier's insurance, current and with limits equal to or above the cargo value, before tendering the load [10]. Indemni's software verifies the driver and the truck at pickup, so the insurance and the checks that help prevent the loss sit in one workflow.

Insurance coverage is subject to eligibility, underwriting, terms, conditions, limitations, and exclusions, and is available only in the states listed on our insurance page. Coverage is underwritten on a surplus lines basis by Chaucer Syndicate 1084 at Lloyd's [10].

Sources

  1. "Insurance Filing Requirements." FMCSA. Last updated March 26, 2026.
  2. 49 CFR 387.301(b), Household goods motor carriers: cargo insurance. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  3. 49 CFR 387.307(a). Electronic Code of Federal Regulations. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  4. 49 U.S.C. § 14706(a), (c), and (e). U.S. Code.
  5. Essex Insurance Co. v. Barrett Moving & Storage, Inc., 885 F.3d 1292. U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. March 21, 2018.
  6. Nicholas Meat, LLC v. PGH Logistics Systems, Inc., No. 1398 WDA 2021 (non-precedential memorandum). Superior Court of Pennsylvania. October 4, 2022.
  7. Kex Distribution v. The Hanover Insurance Co., No. 2:20-cv-874. U.S. District Court for the District of Utah. September 30, 2024.
  8. "Broker and Carrier Fraud and Identity Theft." FMCSA. Last updated April 7, 2025.
  9. "Cyber-Enabled Strategic Cargo Theft Surging," public service announcement. FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center. April 30, 2026.
  10. Indemni Insurance: program terms published on indemni.com/insurance. Accessed November 18, 2026.
  11. "Surplus Lines." National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Updated October 27, 2025.

Related Indemni articles

Review one freight workflow with Indemni.

Bring one current process. Map the evidence, reviewer, exception, and next state that should remain attached to the load.

Book a workflow review